A Balanced Approach to Energy Efficiency

The UK boasts the oldest building stock in Europe, with 5.9 million buildings over a century old. Among these, around 350,000 are listed homes in England, and nearly 600,000 commercial properties date back to before 1919. These historic structures are a vital part of the nation’s heritage, but they also present unique challenges when it comes to improving energy efficiency.

No One-Size-Fits-All Solution

Improving the energy efficiency of older buildings is no simple task. Many factors influence a building’s energy performance, including its location, design, materials, and how it is heated, cooled, and ventilated. The way a building is used by its occupants also plays a crucial role.

While retrofitting modern properties can offer quick solutions, the same approach is not always suitable for historic and traditional buildings. In some cases, certain retrofitting measures may even increase energy consumption during the building’s lifecycle. That said, with thoughtful planning, retaining and adapting historic buildings can contribute to lower carbon emissions without compromising their character.

Barriers to Future-Proofing Historic Buildings

One of the challenges faced by property owners is the requirement for a minimum energy performance rating for rented homes. Since April 2020, landlords must ensure their properties meet at least an EPC (Energy Performance Certificate) rating of E. However, exceptions exist for certain historic buildings, especially where improvements are either impractical or would significantly alter the property’s value or appearance.

Common exemptions include:

• No viable improvements can be made.
• The cost of improvements exceeds the £3,500 cap.
• Upgrades would reduce the property’s value by more than 5%.
• A third party, such as a freeholder, does not permit the upgrades.

A Holistic Approach to Retrofitting

A successful retrofit requires a whole-building approach that takes into account the construction, condition, and significance of the property. By considering how a building is used and its exposure to environmental factors, owners can devise balanced solutions that save energy, maintain comfort, and preserve the building’s historical importance.

Small, reversible interventions should be prioritized before more substantial changes are made. This ensures that any modifications can be undone if necessary, allowing the building’s heritage to remain intact while improving energy efficiency.

Conservation Over Replacement: The Case of Windows and Doors

Original windows and doors are often defining features of historic buildings. Replacing them may seem like an easy way to improve energy efficiency, but it’s usually more sustainable—and better for the environment and heritage—to repair and maintain them instead.

Where possible, employing local craftspeople skilled in traditional methods not only helps preserve the building’s character but also benefits the local economy. Conservation efforts ensure that these original features continue to tell the story of the building’s past while functioning efficiently in the present.

Listed Building Consent: Navigating the Planning Process

If you plan to make alterations to a listed building that may affect its character, you will need approval from your local planning authority. Failing to obtain proper consent can lead to legal repercussions, including criminal prosecution.

It’s advisable to contact your local conservation officer before submitting a planning application. They can provide valuable advice on adapting your plans to make approval more likely while preserving the building’s heritage.

Funding and Resources for Energy Efficiency

For owners of historic buildings, there are several resources available to help fund energy efficiency upgrades. Organisations such as the Energy Saving Trust (England), Nest (Wales), Home Energy Scotland, and Northern Ireland Energy Advice offer grants and loans to help cover the costs of improvements.

Additionally, the UK Government has established an advice line for homeowners and landlords seeking guidance on energy upgrades, ranging from damp control to repointing mortar joints. Historic England has also produced a variety of resources to support building owners in making informed decisions about energy efficiency while preserving heritage value.

Final Thoughts

Future-proofing the UK’s historic buildings requires a careful balance between modern energy efficiency standards and the preservation of their unique character. With a thoughtful, whole-building approach and access to the right resources, it’s possible to reduce carbon emissions without compromising the heritage value of these remarkable properties. By investing in the conservation and adaptation of these buildings, we can ensure they continue to play a role in the UK’s future—both as homes and as part of the nation’s architectural legacy.

Homepage